Farm Bureau weighs in on Supreme Court Hearing of Prop 12 case
California’s Proposition 12 seeks to ban the sale of pork from hogs that don’t meet the state’s arbitrary production standards, even if the pork was raised on farms outside of California. The Supreme Court just decided to hear a challenge to the law by Farm Bureau and the National Pork Producers Council. Travis Cushman, AFBF Senior Counsel for Public Policy, says the decision is a significant milestone.
"It's a very exciting decision, it means the Supreme Court is interested in reviewing whether or not what California has done here is constitutional. That's an incredibly high bar to reach, the Supreme Court takes less than one percent of cases a year that come before it, which means that there are a ton of cases that are very deserving but never had the opportunity. But here, the Supreme Court, at least views that we have reached that bar to decide this important issue," Cushman said.
Prop 12 has far-reaching consequences beyond the pork industry.
"It makes these animal care practices in the hands of voters and not in the hands the folks who actually take care of the animals. That is a very, very unfortunate precedent to have, not just for farmers in the pork industry, but farmers across the country," Cushman said. "Even outside of the animal industry, this law says that voters in one state can dictate how something is created. So, that means that California could tell folks you can't sell products into our state unless you meet our minimum wage requirements for example. So, it has very, very far-reaching implications for folks in every industry."
Cushman outlined what the timeline for the case may look like.
"Next up, we will go through another round of briefing with the Supreme Court, there will also be Amicus opportunities for interested parties to file to court as well," Cushman said. "I expect the oral arguments will happen sometime in October, with a decision by either December or early 2023."
Want more news on this topic? Farm Bureau members may subscribe for a free email news service, featuring the farm and rural topics that interest them most!